top Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Opinions regarding a loan: am I doing the right thing?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Opinions regarding a loan: am I doing the right thing?

    The transmission in my car blew out on Monday. I've only had the car since July so it's a real bummer. It's a newer car with high mileage so it's not under warranty (I almost bought the extended warranty and I'm really kicking myself now!) so I've got to come up with $3,400 for a re-manufactured transmission. I am having the work done at a reputable transmission shop where my best friend's brother and dad work, so I am certain that I am not getting screwed.

    I have the cash to pay for the repairs, but it will completely wipe out my emergency savings. Other than my savings, I also have an investment account that I could pull money from in the event of another emergency, but that would be a last resort because I invested the money when the market was near its lowest point. Pulling money from that account now would be a huge mistake.

    The day before my transmission blew, I had contacted my local bank where I've been doing business for ten years to inquire about a secured personal loan (to be secured by either the investment account or my car) as a means to help rebuild my credit. If approved, the investment account could be used as security, but the money would stay in that account and I would still get the investment benefit.

    Initially, my plan was to borrow around $1k for 12 months at 6.7%. However, I was advised that the minimum I could borrow would be $5k (same rate). Considering my situation, should I just apply for the $5k loan, to be secured by my investment account, to pay for my transmission? To keep that rate, the minimum payback would be 36 months, but I could pay extra on the principal balance/pay off early without penalty.

    I'm leaning toward the loan route. It will provide me with two things: cash to pay for my transmission and help me with credit rebuild.

    Opinions?
    CH7 Filed 2/26/2009 (no asset)
    341 Meeting 4/7/2009
    Discharged 7/10/2009
    Closed 7/28/2009

    #2
    I would go the loan route but then again thats probally one of the reason I filed for bankruptcy as of today !!!!
    Also, I put a rebuilt transmission in my daughters car, of course put in one of my credit cards and right after the 1 yr warranty ran out ... bingo, it blew again... Luckily she put it on craigslist with a blown transmission and it sold in a hour... I was shocked but glad to recoup some of the money to buy her something else...
    Those who live in glass houses should not throw stones
    Chapter 13 filed 10-21-09
    Discharged 4-13-15

    Comment


      #3
      None of this matters now, anyway. My loan application was denied, which blows my mind seeing it would have been 100% secured by CASH on deposit with their institution. There was no risk for them whatsoever.
      CH7 Filed 2/26/2009 (no asset)
      341 Meeting 4/7/2009
      Discharged 7/10/2009
      Closed 7/28/2009

      Comment


        #4
        What kind of car is it? You could get a used transmission from salvage yards and have a mechanic put it in. Should cost half. Ebay is also a good source.
        Filed: 6-7-2010 341: 7-15-2010 DISCHARGED: 9/17/2010

        Comment

        bottom Ad Widget

        Collapse
        Working...
        X