top Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Help with "my" situation

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Question Help with "my" situation

    Hello!

    I'm new to this forum. I've learned a lot just from the threads. However, I'm soo confused on some of the stuff people are talking about. I do have a lawyer, but a really NASTY one.

    Here's my situation:
    My husband and I filed on July 28, 2009. When we met with our lawyer, we told her that we were behind on our mortgage but had worked up a repayment plan with the mortgage company. And that we are on a strict repayment plan that forces us to not be able to pay even our car payments. We were also behind on our vehicles. We are talking about 3-4 months behind. This is due to the fact that before filing, Navy Federal Credit Union used to garnish my husband's paycheck to pay for the loans we have with them. Also, because we're in the military and moved across the country unexpectedly without planning or saving. We told our lawyer that we want to be able to keep the house and the cars. I should have listened to my gut when she lifted her finger motioning to us to stay quiet until she's ready to speak. We couldn't ask her any question if we want her legal advice. She did her calculations and told us that we qualify for a chapter 7. She said her cost is $1200 including the filing fee and that it needs to be paid before she files it. To make the long story short, since my husband is leaving for a deployment, she said it will be best to file it before he leaves so he can sign the paperwork. So we rushed to do it, used the money we were saving to pay the mortgage and the cars, hence, I'm left with our dillemas.

    Here are the problems:
    1. We are still behind on our mortgage and cars. Properties we want to keep.
    2. We already filed for a Chapter 7.
    3. We have a very rude, very direct, won't answer any question lawyer.
    4. We have a trustee hearing this Monday.

    Here's what happened to our mortgage:
    Before bankcruptcy, we were able to work out a repayment plan with our mortgage company. Our mortgage is $1350 a month. We were being forced to pay $2300/mo to keep the house out of forclosure. We have asked them to move the due date and cancelled on that repayment plan a few times because it was just really hard to come up with that amount. Since we have no money at all to pay the lawyer, we used the money we have saved up to pay her, asked the bank if we can move the due date again. Yes, I wasn't given the answer I wanted to hear. They basically told us that they can't but if we are able to pay at least two mortgage payments, that they should be able to do the repayment plan again. They told me to call at a certain date, and I did, but when I called, since the BK have already been filed, I was told that they filed a "motion of release." They wouldn't take my payment. But they said that they can ask their lawyer to see if I can still make a payment and how much. They told me to call two days after. I did, and I was told that the only amount they would accept is the total amount past due which is $6300. I don't have that amount. And they told me to talk to my lawyer when I asked how long I have to come up with that amount.

    I contacted our lawyer via email since there is no direct line to her office, told her about the situation. After two days of waiting for a respond from her, she claims that we told her that we were current on our mortgage. And that if she had known, she would have adviced us to file for a Chapter 13. So, she tells us to schedule an appointment with her. So I did. I went yesterday to meet her. Scared to death of what's going to happen. Our house is in Florida, we live in California now. My husband might not be able to re-enlist in the military due to tenures and things. We intend to go back to Florida where living is more affordable for our family. And I can't go to work without a car. The same with him. I'm uneducated with BKs. It doesn't help that my husband is away and cannot ask his legal officers because he doesn't want to be talked about on the ship. I'm desperate. When I saw my lawyer yesterday, she was rude to me and treated me like a dirty rag. Our conversation went from "Why are you here?," then I told her, "There's nothing I can do, wait for the motion to be recorded", (apparently, the mortgage company hasn't filed the motion yet, because she checked on her computer and she hasn't received a letter. Then, she said we have 14 days to fight it, and she will require $1200 to fight it. I was devastated after hearing this. She goes on to tell me "Go!, there's nothing I can do, I've already told you what to do, I've sent you fliers with your paperwork, you're clogging up my morning. GO!" I've never felt so low in my life, and I tried to collect myself and get up but I forgot to ask her another question that I meant to ask. So instead of fighting with her and not get my question answered, I swallowed my pride and asked the question anyway. In which she said, "GO! talk to Jennifer, I don't answer those questions." This is a question pertaining to a credit card that a creditor wants to reaffirm, in which we want to do to help rebuild our credit. So I talked to her assistant, who by the way, is much nicer than her. But since her assistant couldn't answer the question, she said she would just get back with me. And I went on my way. I got in the car, felt worst than I did in the past few days. I couldn't believe I was treated that way. I'm not very assertive at all. I believe in Karma and I'm a good person. I wouldn't talk to anyone the way she talked to me. No matter what. I might have filed for bankcruptcy, but I'm still a person, and I have principles. I'm doing this to get back on our feet and provide for our children, for our survival. She on the other hand, feels like doing this for the money.

    Anyway, I still have questions left anunswered. One mistake we've realized is that we relied on our lawyer to give us all the answers, and since I'm getting what we paid for, she wouldn't give us any answers. Finding this website helps. It answered a few of questions, but since most cases are different, I couldn't really understand some of it. I did speak to another lawyer, I'm contemplating on hiring another one to represent us. He was honest and told me that he can take our case, but it will cost us more money. He said that any repayment plans are cancelled when you file for BK. He basically suggested working it out with our current lawyer.

    Our trustee meeting is tomorrow. I know he/she will ask if we are current on the loans. Our goal is to keep the vehicles and the house. My lawyer is not going to be there, she has another lawyer standing for her. I've learned here that when you go to this meeting that the trustee always finds something to sell. So my questions are:
    1. What can happen once we tell the trustee that we are behind on the mortgage and the cars?
    2. What actions can the mortgage company take while we are in this process?
    3. Does it sound like we have a chance of losing the house?
    4. If it's looking like its going to be taken, can we ask to convert it to a Chapter 13?
    5. If it gets converted to a Chapter 13, can my lawyer charge me more?
    6. Am I better off losing the house in a Chapter 7?
    7. What about the cars?
    8. Has anyone been able to make payments to a trustee on a Chapter 7. (Like, can I still keep the Chapter 7, then promise to make the past due payments in a period of 4-5 months?)

    I'm reading the posts here today to prepare for Monday. But I would appreciate any advice anyone can give me. Thanks.

    #2
    Okay, so wow is the word I will use to temper what I write now... just wow. I will say this, in all the confusion, the attorney may have believed that your were current on your "payment" plan and paying the lawyer with those funds may have made it worse.

    The lender is absolutely in its rights to Motion for Relief from the Automatic Stay (MFRS) and will probably win it. Plus, you don't even live in the house, so you have no homestead protection either. I don't even know what your paperwork looks like, but that makes it more interesting to me.


    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    1. What can happen once we tell the trustee that we are behind on the mortgage and the cars?
    Doesn't matter, it's up to the creditors to take action on that property by exercising their right for an MFRS to be granted, and then to seek recovery under your State's non-bankruptcy laws and process (foreclosure/repossession).

    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    2. What actions can the mortgage company take while we are in this process?
    Nothing until they submit the MFRS and have it granted. It reads as though they have already done this, so it is in the works.

    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    3. Does it sound like we have a chance of losing the house?
    Absolutely.

    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    4. If it's looking like its going to be taken, can we ask to convert it to a Chapter 13?
    Yes, you can convert to a Chapter 13 but you have to "ask" the Court to allow it by a Motion to Convert to Chapter 13.

    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    5. If it gets converted to a Chapter 13, can my lawyer charge me more?
    Absolutely yes. Chapter 13s take more work. You may have to get a new attorney, if this one isn't that great.

    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    6. Am I better off losing the house in a Chapter 7?
    Don't know. How upside down are you on the house? In other words, how much do you owe with all encumbrances (mortgages)... versus how much the property is worth. If it's worth 10% less than you owe... dump it.

    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    7. What about the cars?
    No different in treatment than any other secured property like your home. They can file an MFRS and then repossess the car after being granted relief.

    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    8. Has anyone been able to make payments to a trustee on a Chapter 7. (Like, can I still keep the Chapter 7, then promise to make the past due payments in a period of 4-5 months?)
    No. This is not the purpose of a Chapter 7.

    Originally posted by seconds View Post
    I'm reading the posts here today to prepare for Monday. But I would appreciate any advice anyone can give me. Thanks.
    Ask more questions... we are here.
    Chapter 7 (No Asset/Non-Consumer) Filed (Pro Se) 7/08 (converted from Chapter 13 - 2/10)
    Status: (Auto) Discharged and Closed! 5/10
    Visit My BKForum Blog: justbroke's Blog

    Any advice provided is not legal advice, but simply the musings of a fellow bankrupt.

    Comment


      #3
      Thanks for the reply. My lawyer refused to listen to anything we have to say from the beginning. We were telling her our situation but she insisted to not worry about it. She knew about the repayment plan we have with the mortgage company and the late payment on the cars. She made it impossible to speak or ask questions when we were at her office. From your response, it sounds like we got ripped off. Now, worst case scenario, I might just let the house go. But we need the cars. I feel like I should just ask to convert to a chapter 13 and hire a different lawyer. I guess I'll never know until Monday. I'm so scared. Question: Do I ask at the hearing for the conversion? Or will the trustee decide that for us?

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by seconds View Post
        Question: Do I ask at the hearing for the conversion? Or will the trustee decide that for us?
        Yes, it's a hearing for conversion. Also, if you really feel your lawyer didn't earn their fee, you can also petition the court to disgorge their wages.

        When you get to your 341 Meeting, let the Trustee know.
        Chapter 7 (No Asset/Non-Consumer) Filed (Pro Se) 7/08 (converted from Chapter 13 - 2/10)
        Status: (Auto) Discharged and Closed! 5/10
        Visit My BKForum Blog: justbroke's Blog

        Any advice provided is not legal advice, but simply the musings of a fellow bankrupt.

        Comment


          #5
          I will need to make a decision on whether I still want the house or not. But question: I reaffirmed one of the cars, and i intend to do both. My lawyer said my lender doesn't need to send us an agreement on the other one. And my lawyer signed the agreement as well. Will the cars still get repossessed? I'm two months behind on the other vehicle.

          Comment


            #6
            You can not sign a reaffirmation when you are already in breach of contract. Whether the first car gets repossessed or not, is whether it is current and you are paying as agreed. Whether your reaffirmation(s) are approved will also depend on the loan status, whether your District allows reaffirmations, and whether they are an undue hardship on you, in the Judge's opinion. (Since your lawyer signed one of them, the Judge may not need to perform the hardship test.)
            Chapter 7 (No Asset/Non-Consumer) Filed (Pro Se) 7/08 (converted from Chapter 13 - 2/10)
            Status: (Auto) Discharged and Closed! 5/10
            Visit My BKForum Blog: justbroke's Blog

            Any advice provided is not legal advice, but simply the musings of a fellow bankrupt.

            Comment


              #7
              So as I'm reading your answers I guess I have options to explore. But:

              1. If I ask to convert to a chapter 13, do you suggest that I retain a lawyer, not necessarily my lawyer now?
              2. I think according to our means test, we have an excess of $130 every month. If I do not keep my lawyer, and ask to convert, will I have a hard time proving that we can afford the repayment plan?
              3. I can dump my lawyer right?
              4. Which is harder to establish a credit, 7 or 13?

              And if I decide to just go on with the Chapter 7, I will lose my house, and my cars...
              1. How hard is it to get a couple of vehicles before getting a discharge with a really crappy credit? We're talking about really low FICO scores and late payments?
              2. Can a judge decide to let us keep the cars even when we're behind on payments?
              3. What if we decide to keep the 7, we're still late on the car payments, but catch up before it closes? Is there such thing? Do I have to be current before or after our Trustee meeting?

              I've read a thread where people have actually gotten loans for cars. I'm wondering if we lose the cars by repo, how soon can we get a loan? Will the BK have to discharged first?

              I really appreciate your help. Sorry if I sound stupid about all of these. My lawyer is really NO HELP at all. These are the questions I want to ask, but not been able to because she keeps throwing me out of her office.

              Thanks again.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                1. If I ask to convert to a chapter 13, do you suggest that I retain a lawyer, not necessarily my lawyer now?
                If you are having difficulty working with this lawyer on a Chapter 7, you would have a worse time with a Chapter 13 as they are more involved!

                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                2. I think according to our means test, we have an excess of $130 every month. If I do not keep my lawyer, and ask to convert, will I have a hard time proving that we can afford the repayment plan?
                You can actually be in a plan which has a $0.00 payment to unsecured creditors! (I am in such a Plan.) I pay all my secured debt through the Trustee as well as my IRS priority tax debt.

                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                3. I can dump my lawyer right?
                Yes, anyone can dump their lawyer with or without cause. You will have to officially "fire" the lawyer, and they will generally file the motion to be released as counsel themselves.

                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                4. Which is harder to establish a credit, 7 or 13?
                It depends on your credit situation before filing. Many Chapter 7 debtors have received creditor offers in as little as 2 months after close of their case!

                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                1. How hard is it to get a couple of vehicles before getting a discharge with a really crappy credit? We're talking about really low FICO scores and late payments?
                Your only recourse would be 722 Redemption (US Bank)... and their interest rates are high. But they do finance cars for Chapter 13 debtors.

                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                2. Can a judge decide to let us keep the cars even when we're behind on payments?
                Absolutely not. This is not even a discussion on this. Creditors have rights and especially "secured" creditors.

                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                3. What if we decide to keep the 7, we're still late on the car payments, but catch up before it closes? Is there such thing? Do I have to be current before or after our Trustee meeting?
                Doesn't matter if you catch up before close. You have to catch up before discharge. Even so, the lender will probably file a Motion for Relief from the Automatic Stay (MFRS) immediately upon you filing anyhow... so that they can exercise their rights.

                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                I've read a thread where people have actually gotten loans for cars. I'm wondering if we lose the cars by repo, how soon can we get a loan? Will the BK have to discharged first?
                The BK would certainly need to be discharged at a minimum, and likely needs to be closed too.

                Originally posted by seconds View Post
                I really appreciate your help. Sorry if I sound stupid about all of these. My lawyer is really NO HELP at all. These are the questions I want to ask, but not been able to because she keeps throwing me out of her office.
                The only stupid question is the unasked question.
                Chapter 7 (No Asset/Non-Consumer) Filed (Pro Se) 7/08 (converted from Chapter 13 - 2/10)
                Status: (Auto) Discharged and Closed! 5/10
                Visit My BKForum Blog: justbroke's Blog

                Any advice provided is not legal advice, but simply the musings of a fellow bankrupt.

                Comment


                  #9
                  So I convert to Chapter 13, what's being calculated in it? The amount past due, or the entire amount of the loans? I don't want to get stuck in paying really high amount only to file a chapter 7 after. It will defeat our purpose of filing for BK.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by seconds View Post
                    So I convert to Chapter 13, what's being calculated in it? The amount past due, or the entire amount of the loans?
                    Both. You'll make payments on the arrears (past due amounts), and will continue payments on the regular loan.

                    Originally posted by seconds View Post
                    I don't want to get stuck in paying really high amount only to file a chapter 7 after. It will defeat our purpose of filing for BK.
                    This may still occur. However, if you're trying to save property, you have no choice but to do a Chapter 13.
                    Chapter 7 (No Asset/Non-Consumer) Filed (Pro Se) 7/08 (converted from Chapter 13 - 2/10)
                    Status: (Auto) Discharged and Closed! 5/10
                    Visit My BKForum Blog: justbroke's Blog

                    Any advice provided is not legal advice, but simply the musings of a fellow bankrupt.

                    Comment

                    bottom Ad Widget

                    Collapse
                    Working...
                    X