top Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So the rat (me) in the maze game started today - behind on mortgage and CH7.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    So the rat (me) in the maze game started today - behind on mortgage and CH7.

    Didnt know which forum was better for this one (FC or CH7), so I guess I ll go here. Also, this is another of my "mainly this is a place to vent and share my experiences with others post" as Im pretty there is nothing more I can do....but always willing to hear suggestions from others!!

    As some know from other posts I filed CH7 on 4/20/11. I was behind on my mortgage, but was hoping I could still have my lender (Chase) just agree to the repayment plan we had set up before I filed. Well...no go on the payment plan. Chase says once I filed that is no longer valid, now they said that isnt to say they will not eventually agree to some new plan but the original plan is no longer valid.

    Chase has already filed for a motion to lift stay (pretty quick!), but that is pretty standard fare from what I understand. Chase had NOT filed any official foreclosure paperwork prior to my filing. SO, I got the form from Chase that I and my attorney signed allowing us to speak in spite of the stay being in effect since my goal is to keep the house if possible.

    Anyway, as I said the repayment plan no longer in place, and they say my current options are either pay arrears in full (Im unable to do that at present) - OR - I MUST start with an attempt at loan modification. I guess if they will give me one that would be ok - but I read nothing but horror stories about this loan mod process.

    SO, I sent the paperwork back applying for a modification - it actually looks like MAYBE I barely qualify depending on how they look at the numbers. My current payment is over the 31% of income level so I would qualify - but that is including some short term "extra" escrow payments for taxes they are taking this year - my house was brand new so during the first year they didnt take any and are now making up for it. Once those go away my "normal" payment is right at that 31% threshold so I probably wouldnt qualify. But in any case, from all I read at worst case scenario this will buy me some time before they start any FC proceedings so I might as well apply, right?

    As I was talking to the Chase SUPERVISOR (have already learned the normal CSRs are basically useless!!) and he was explaining everything, he said - on his own - that not only will the FC proceedings be delayed while they review my mod application etc, that the MLS will ALSO be halted! This was good news to me, because not only would that slow any possible official NOD being filed til at least after my CH7 discharge, if Chase was so inclined (doubtful they are in big hurry here in AZ I know), BUT my main concern is that I of course will be liable for any attorneys fees that are being generated for the MLS etc.

    Of course I immediately called the attorney who filed the MLS for Chase and told him I was in the mod process and that my understanding was that his actions were to stop (again Im not as concerned with the actual filing etc as I am with how much it is costing me in the end!! Less lawyer work means less money!). The atty of course said, that is true, but only AFTER we are notified and confirmed that you are actually being "reviewed" for the modification.

    SO, I ask him what that means? I tell him I have turned in the paperwork at Chase's request, and they are supposed to notify of whether I am approved for a trial mod or whatever. What else does he need? He tells me (and I here him typing in the background) that he is checking with Chase as to the status.....oh brother!!

    SO, I can tell already this entire process is going to require constant supervision from me to make sure that not only does the mod process move forward (for better or worse), but that the right hand knows what the left is doing. Otherwise I can foresee my "additional" amounts due to Chase before I can cure any default skyrocketing! This is important because it is very possible that as all this drags on for months more, and I am able to save some bucks, I may end up just curing the default or entering into a new and revised payment plan if the modification is not approved.

    I ll update this as it goes....but I can tell it will be fun few months. Just as TRYING to give one of my cars back to the bank has been already!

    Im chalking all of this up to "consequences of my past actions".

    Thanks for listening!

    #2
    Did they say you had to pay all your arrears, or just what you are contrctually due for? I want to convert by chapter 13 to a 7, but I fear losing my home. I could catch up my contractually due payments, but I can't catch up my escrow shortfall (they paid property taxes that were being paid in my chapter 13 plan). I am curious what Chase told you.

    Comment


      #3
      Yes, I can pay only my late payments, PLUS fees (including attorney's fees as my post discusses). Now as I have always paid my taxes, ins, mortgage ins etc in my escrow my late payments included all those items. Not sure how it would work for you with the CH13 issue etc...but I cant yet repay all my back payments anyway - though I am banking every penny in case that becomes my best option I at least may have a shot at it by the time it comes.


      Just a quick update - I did call back to Chase this morning (remember I said I am going to have to shepard this thing through every step!) and confirmed they did in fact receive and enter my loan mod application information. So, as always I got a manager on the phone - actually this woman was pretty sharp and helpful - who says now I wait for a loan mod underwriter to take over my account, and in the meantime the Motion to lift stay is put on hold (continued in court terms) until the review of loan mod is finished - typically about 45-60 days. She says realistically at this stage it is unlikely they will pursue the motion to lift the stay before discharge since I am in this review stage. I will still call the Chase lawyers who filed the motion today to confirm this! Eventually even after discharge they will have to petition the court to remove the property from the estate, but that is a formality. In the meantime all foreclosure proceedings are on hold (supposedly!). Obviously I will be watching closely.

      Unfortunately I am already now responsible for about 600.00 in additional fees due to the legal action already filed, but she says they will amortize that into the modified loan if offered. She also said that IF IF I am NOT offered a permanent loan mod for any reason later, there is the very real possibility of another forebearance (repayment plan) plan later in the process....they just MUST review loan mod possibilities first (I think this is because they get money from the govt for mods!). Also, she confirmed that even with the modification, it is likely the loan will NOT be reaffirmed even in the newly modified state.

      She was actually pretty smart and I felt pretty confident I knew where things stood after our conversation.

      Updates to follow as warranted.

      Comment


        #4
        SO, as expected, I have had to really keep on every little aspect of this process. I have had to make numerous phone calls both to Chase BK department and the law firm hired by Chase in Phoenix to file the motion to lift stay to make sure they are on same page, BUT when I spoke to the lawyer this morning, he did in fact confirm they want them to "put on hold" the Motion to lift proceedings. When I asked what exactly that meant (since they have already filed to motion!), he said most likely they will WITHDRAW the motion for relief from stay, and I will be noticed on that withdrawal (they did in fact notice me directly as well as my attorney on the filing itself).

        So, now I will wait a few days to hear from the Chase Loan Mod "Underwriter/Case Manager" and for notice from the law firm described above.

        Not fun having to manage every aspect of this, but I suppose it is better than just letting it all fall apart and having to start over, or worse!

        Im really curious as to whether I will qualify for a loan mod.....we ll see I guess!

        But, at least for now at a minimum I have bought some more time before any official FC proceedings take place.

        Comment


          #5
          GOOD LUCK And best wishes!!!!!! I guess I'm with you - I never "assume" things will work...have annoyed MANY people with that attitude - spouse and atty included - but I always expect the worst :-( Again, your work has paid off!!!!!

          Comment


            #6
            Periodic update (if anyone cares!) - Called Chase again today - they have confirmed I now have a Loan Mod underwriter assigned and a "welcome" package is on its way to me (how exciting! - lol!). I also contacted the Chase attorney again and his exact words were "I am just waiting for some last information and we will be filing a withdrawal of the motion requesting a lifting of the automatic stay." In other words they will NOT be asking to lift the stay at this time - which is good from a time standpoint (as they would have to do this in order to move forward with any FC proceedings), AND more importantly a cost standpoint since all legal fees are now added to my loan balance!

            So, now my big wonders (and they are directly related to the BK at this point) is which loan mod program I will get, if any? In theory I qualify for FHA HAMP, but they have Debt to Income ratios that must be met (total debt monthly payments cannot be more than 55%), which is no problem once the BK is discharged...but THEN there are aspects to qualification that if I have TOO MUCH available income they cannot do a modification. There are other FHA loan restructurings available, BUT for those you CANNOT have filed BK.

            We ll see....I may get denied for all possibilities - two that I would qualify for except that I ve filed BK - and another that I would qualify for even with the BK filing, except that because I would have TOO much disposable income because of the BK!

            Fun stuff.

            Comment


              #7
              Periodic Update - today got the official "welcome" package for the modification package in the mail AND PACER shows the motion to WITHDRAW the request to lift the stay. SO, so far they are doing what they said they would and at least with the motion to withdraw in place I know at a minimum I have another month or two while they review this modification request. So even if in the end I DONT work out something (which I want to do badly) with Chase, I at least have another 4-5 months at the earliest before I have to be out.

              Comment


                #8
                First, best wishes to you!!!! Second, thank you for keeping us updated!

                Originally posted by sh9730 View Post
                Periodic Update - today got the official "welcome" package for the modification package in the mail AND PACER shows the motion to WITHDRAW the request to lift the stay. SO, so far they are doing what they said they would and at least with the motion to withdraw in place I know at a minimum I have another month or two while they review this modification request. So even if in the end I DONT work out something (which I want to do badly) with Chase, I at least have another 4-5 months at the earliest before I have to be out.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Yes, thanks for keeping the thread updated!! Lots of us are reading your 'saga'.
                  ~~ Filed Over Median Income Chapter 7: 12/17/2010 ~~ 341 Held: 1/12/2011 ~~ Discharged: 03/16/2011 ~~
                  Not an attorney - just an opinionated woman.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    I'm reading now, too!

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Just a slight update today. I actually got to speak with my Chase "Relationship Manager" (RM). She is just the coordinator of everything and doesnt make any decisions, but she did catch that I forgot to fill out one line on a form they needed (I really had missed it!), and asked that I refax it....she confirmed she got it and now she has an appraisal (BPO) done on my house, and gets a new escrow analysis done and then sends the entire package to the underwriter.

                      Hey, Im glad she found that little thing I missed! I have heard many stories about how they just deny you the mod for improper paperwork...plus I have her DIRECT phone number.

                      We ll see...she didnt really know how it worked at all since I am in active BK. That is more of an underwriter issue and they probably wont even get the file for another week.

                      OH, also I got my paperwork from the Chase attorneys today for the withdrawal of the Motion to Lift the Stay - it had a completely different NOTE (some other address completely) attached! Called the attorney and he says for the withdrawal there shouldnt even have been a note attached and that the paperwork filed with the court for the withdrawal did not....

                      Fun stuff. I think Im in a waiting pattern for a week or so now.....

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Latest - as expected not too much happening, but I am glad I am treating this like a part time job and following up frequently. Today I called Chase and the lady checked on my file and said "Oh, we have everything done (the BPO and escrow analysis) to move this on to underwriting. I had a tickler set to check on this and call you Thursday, but since this is all done already we can save a few days!".

                        So, now its onto underwriting. Who knows how long that will take or what they will say....

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Since its been awhile I just thought I would update this. I have been checking weekly on my modification status but no further progress. Still in underwriting and they do not require any more information and it has not been denied or anything either.

                          Im not pushing real hard right now since I would really prefer this take place AFTER my BK discharge, which I hope is August 3rd (had my 341 last week) so there is no possibility of the bank wanting to tie the loan mod to a reaffirmation agreement. Im in AZ and the BK judges wont sign it anyway, but why even confuse things.

                          PLUS, from everything I read about with these mods (and lately more have been getting approved!), you start with just a single "normal" revised payment on your trial, then it becomes permanent, and all the arrears go to the end of the loan. If thats what happens it will be nice for me to have a little emergency fund post BK. Since every month they take to "review" my mod I am not making a payment and banking that money, Im fine with them taking their time reviewing as long as they arent doing any foreclosure proceedings, which they are not at present.

                          Just in case I am of course keeping all this money in the bank in case I have to come up with a lump sum for any reason (i.e. if the mod is denied and I have to do a "repayment" plan again - see first post in this thread), , but in the meantime Im happy for them to take their time until my bk discharge.

                          Comment

                          bottom Ad Widget

                          Collapse
                          Working...
                          X